
A few weeks ago, I asked for feedback on the Alienware Area 51 m5790 and other suggestions for a solid work laptop that was also gaming capable.
My reasoning was that I need: a) a good, fast machine for my brand of multitasking, and b) a gaming machine to support Busy Gamer News and side projects such as
video editing.
Any machine that's fast enough for
Half-Life 2 and
Halo 2 on Vista should hopefully stand up to my RAM- and CPU- intensive work style, which has taken down many an inferior notebook provided to me by employers over the years. I like to keep dozens of e-mails, documents and Web pages open while I flip quickly between various tasks. I have yet to find a portable that won't crash if I don't reboot it every few days. And that's a problem, because I like to keep my previous day's work in progress open and ready to pick up where I left off the next morning.
Alienware was my first choice for obvious reasons (raw power, customization options and "cool" factor), but I backed off for awhile to investigate laptops from HP and Toshiba. All had pluses and minuses. The HP dv9000t offered a beautiful screen and lots of customization options. It was nearly as fast and would be ready a week before the Alienware. Plus, I could order it online from Costco at a discount.
I came very close to getting the HP. It offered good power and lots of extras (tuner card, webcam) for substantially less than the Alienware. But I chose to sleep on it, and the next morning decided against it for one crucial reason: durability. After watching
this video review in particular, I was certain the HP would not stand up to much travel. If I only wanted to park it in my office and occasionally work in bed or drag it down to the living room, it would be a great choice. But taking it out to clients and impromptu WiFi-enabled and highly caffeinated workspots? I don't think so.
Why not a MacBook? As tempting it is, I need Vista so I can ramp up on the new OS, which will only help me as a consultant. And I'm wary of the whole "dual boot" thing, having suffered through many such "solutions" during my many years as an Apple fanatic.
First impressions
I've not bought a laptop for myself since the 68K PowerBooks in the early '90s, but I had heard great things about Alienware so I was on pins and needles while I waited for my system to be built and delivered. When I placed the order over the phone, I tried to pressure the sales rep into offering a discount and/or quicker delivery than the three weeks cited on the Web site. He wouldn't give any on price, but offered to expedite my order to shave about a week off the delivery date.
However, as I watched the status of my laptop remain stuck in various stages of Alienware's 9-step process, I became wary and finally threatened to cancel my order if they didn't expedite it. That did it. The next day, it cleared testing (after three days of sitting without any software installed) and shipped! Alas, it takes about 5 business days for a laptop to ship from Miami to Seattle (there's no overnight shipping option), so I still had to wait, wait and wait some more.
When the m5790 finally arrived, I was both blown away and a bit disappointed at first. Since there's no local store where I could try the system out before ordering, I was shocked at how big it is. It's like a tank! But very, very smooth and shiny. Not at all how I pictured it. It also had some unsightly smudges near the trackpad (that I eventually wiped clean), and several of the DVD sleeves in the instruction binder were torn loose. And there was a mystery item that I still don't know what to do with - possibly some test cable I don't need. I think someone really rushed to get my laptop ready to make the day's last FedEx pickup!
The first thing I did was upgrade from Vista Home Basic (the cheapest option available when I ordered) to Vista Ultimate, which I secured at a hefty discount. This messed up my sound driver, but fortunately Vista had warned me that it might be a problem and I had already downloaded new drivers. Then I loaded up Office 2007, moved my work documents, and I was mostly ready for business.
I've been using it for two days now, and it is fast and slick. Because it's so shiny, I've named it Kaylee. I'm having to adjust to Vista, which didn't impress me at first but it's growing on me. That
new Apple ad nails it: The system is constantly asking my permission for stuff, even just to load a Flash element for a Web page that I visited twice already. But there are some improvements that make me more efficient - or I suspect they will once I get used to them. Office has an all new layout, and it's taking time to get it set up the way that I like (10 minutes just to find the Options).
I haven't played much in the way of games - just the bundled
Solitaire and
Mahjong Titans games, which are quite nice and will even save your progress when you quit. I plan to install
Dungeon Siege II (which I never got around to playing though I loved the original),
Doom 3 and a few other more intensive games as well as some of the new HD casual games. I'll let you know how they do. I didn't max out the system with the fastest video card or overclocked processor, but so far it's been plenty fast enough.
I'll post further impressions in a week or so once I've had a chance to haul it around and play some games.
-=Gamewatcher