HD-DVD First Impressions
I know, I haven't kept up my blog much since I started at Big Fish Games. Truth is, I've been really busy. I love my job, and most of my free time goes into work, family or games. It's amazing that I've managed to keep this site going.
Today I took a long overdue day off to catch up on housework and bills, and decided to take advantage of some birthday gift cards and Best Buy coupons to get the Toshiba HD-DVD player at a hefty discount.
I had been thinking I'd wait for the Xbox external HD-DVD drive, but a few things convinced me to get the standalone player.
- We can enjoy high-def DVDs and upscale our vast library of DVDs.
- Our existing DVD player is buggy as hell - it screws up on a lot of movies. To date, I've never seen the end of The Two Towers without skipping past some stuttering scenes.
- We had already bought Serenity on HD-DVD on Joss Whedon's birthday and it was, like, just sitting there.
If you who know me, you probably know I'm a videophile dating back almost two decades. I still have a laserdisc player and more than 100 discs for it. And almost 1000 DVD titles.
I've decided that, for now, I'm not interested in Blu-Ray. My understanding is that it has fewer features and in many cases poorer video and the player costs twice the money. No thanks. Maybe I'll get a PS3 (still on the fence), and if so, problem solved.
First things first. HD-DVD isn't for everyone. Don't even consider it unless you:
- Own an HDTV made in the past couple years that has either an HDMI port or DVI with HDCP support (check your manual).
- Have at least five speakers and a subwoofer attached to a receiver capable of 5.1 surround sound or better. Bonus points if it decodes DTS.
- Do your homework before you shop.
I spent a few days scoping the threads at
AVSForum. com to ensure I knew what I needed, had a compatible TV, etc. The sales clerk at Best Buy couldn't even give me the right answer about whether there was an HDMI cable in the box. I was certain I had read there was one, but couldn't find definitive info on the box. The clerk said there wasn't and tried to sell me a 4-foot cable for $100 (ow!). Instead, I drove a few miles to Video Only and got a 6-foot cable for $30 and a DVI adapter (since my TV is a couple years old and doesn't have an actual HDMI input) for another $30.
If I'd planned ahead, I could have ordered an adapter for $5 at
Monoprice.com. (They have cables, too, in the $15 range.) It's all digital, so having a gold-plated cable shouldn't make all that much difference.
Anyway, when I got home, I found the Toshiba HD-A1 player does include the HDMI cable - so all I needed was the adapter. Best Buy's adapter was roughly the same price as Video Only's (amazingly), so the clerk actually lost them a sale.
Setup was pretty simple. I just unplugged my old player, used my existing optical audio cable, plugged in the HDMI cable and adapter, and turned it all on. I had to press the V.Output button a few times on the HD-DVD remote until I got picture.
I put in Serenity and, wow! No blur, no glitching - just smooth picture. Skin tones were a little off until I realized I had my TV set to a tweaked Vivid setting that I no longer needed with such a pure picture source (still need to do some calibration). I experimented with 720p and 1080i, and found I liked the 1080i slightly better even though I'm sure my TV's native resolution is 720p.
I also put in a regular Firefly DVD and a few other discs and found playback was equally smooth - no blurring or glitching except during fast forward scan. Even crappy DVDs looked remarkably better.
What really stunned me, though, was the sound. I've had surround sound for years. But the HD-DVD, even with the exact same speakers and setup, just seemed to envelope me in its matrix. At one point, it felt like I was in Serenity!
My main regret is that I can no longer conveniently bounce DVD video or audio to smaller kitchen TV and speakers that we recently added so we could watch Tivo or movies while we cooked or did dishes. When outputting high-end audio and video, the HD-A1's lower end connections are shut off. Rats! I'm sure there's a way to make it work, but it would probably cost twice as much as the HD player.
Otherwise, I'm quite enjoying the player. The loading time is as horrible as they say: a minute plus when you turn it on. But switching discs once it's booted up isn't too bad, and the improvements in picture and sound make it well worth it.
I did have one regular DVD (Shrek) freeze up completely about 10 minutes in, so more testing is clearly needed. The player can be connected to the Internet for firmware updates (including one that should improve disc compatibility), so one night this week I'll disconnect my Ethernet cable from my 360 and plug it into the Toshiba to see if the experience gets even better.
--Gamewatcher